Fresh North End renovation sells for $4.3 million

Like this page on Facebook Tweet about this page on Twitter Pin this on Pinterest +1 this on Google+

Garden Road is considered one of the North End’s prime streets, and for several good reasons. It’s in a quiet neighborhood, six streets north of the Palm Beach Country Club. The street is also wider with deeper lots than many of its North End neighbors — and it has an alley, allowing garages to be placed in the rear of the house rather than facing the street. No wonder that the street consistently has been popular with homebuyers: Many of the houses are newer — or newly remodeled. The latter category includes a midblock, four-bedroom house at 235 Garden Road that recently changed hands after spending less than three months in the Palm Beach Board of Realtors’ Multiple Listing Service.

Agent Gary Pohrer of Douglas Elliman wasn’t surprised that the house sold quickly or that it fetched a recorded $4.3 million. He had priced the house, which stands on a lot measuring a third of an acre, at just under $4.6 million.

“It was in the sweet spot of the price range for getting a decent-size lot,” Pohrer said.

The house has 4,283 square feet of living space, inside and out. It was remodeled by its seller, Bruce A. Percelay, who bought the property in April 2015 for $3.72 million. The renovation included the installation of impact-resistant windows and doors as well as a new plumbing and electrical systems. The house also has a new kitchen and baths among its interior improvements.

Agent Heather Bretzlaff of the Corcoran Group acted on behalf of the buyer and, like Pohrer, declined to comment about her client. The buyer was a limited liability company named Starboard LLC, according to the deed recorded on Jan. 18. That company is linked in public records to Thomas F. Bigony of Boston, whose career included serving as co-chairman and CEO of Harvey Building Products of Waltham, Mass. The Bigony family and another family sold their majority stake in that firm to a private equity firm in 2015, retaining a minority ownership interest. The LLC that bought the Garden Road house is managed by Boston attorney Jeffrey W. Roberts.

Seller Percelay is chairman and founder of The Mount Vernon Co., a Boston-based real estate investment firm that specializes in acquiring apartment buildings in Massachusetts. Its portfolio also includes hotels, commercial buildings and vacation properties.

Pohrer is helping Percelay and his wife, Elizabeth, house-hunt on the island.

“We enjoy Palm Beach so much, we are now looking for a larger home,” Bruce Percelay said.

On the Mizner trail — First-generation Palm Beach architect Addison Mizner will be forever credited with revolutionizing the look of Palm Beach in the 1920s with his fanciful interpretations of Mediterranean style.

Many of his houses and mansions, however, are today only the stuff of memories, having been razed to make way for the new in the decades before the establishment of the Landmarks Preservation Commission in the late 1970s.

Today, the Mizner designs that are still standing are much revered — and often landmarked.

Over the past two months, three such houses have been listed for sale, bringing to five the number of Mizner properties available to house hunters in the Estate Section and Midtown, according to the local MLS.

Listed at $24.9 million, a 1921 landmarked house known as Audita overlooks the Atlantic Ocean at 91 Middle Road. That’s a newly assigned address, because the house is the first property to be carved from the former estate assembled by the late billionaire John W. Kluge. For years, Audita was part of 89 Middle Road, a 4-acre property that seasonal Palm Beacher Sir Peter Wood bought last year for a recorded $39 million. He is in the process of subdividing the rest of the estate for redevelopment.

Kluge used Audita, built in 1921, as a guesthouse. Broker Christian J. Angle of Christian Angle Real Estate has the listing for the four-bedroom house, which stands on a lot measuring a little less than an acre and faces 150 feet of beachfront across South Ocean Boulevard. The parcel extends 250 feet west of the coastal road and includes a separate guesthouse and two-car garage.

When Wood bought the estate, he was represented by agent John O. Pickett III of Brown Harris Stevens opposite four co-listing agents: Carole Hogan and Carol Digges, also of Brown Harris Stevens, and Dana Koch and Paulette Koch of the Corcoran Group.

About a half-mile northwest of the property is another recent Mizner addition to the market. Casa del Ensueños was built in 1923 at 800 S. County Road and is one of the architect’s rare lake-front designs. Sotheby’s International Realty agents Cristina Condon and Jean Lembcke listed the 1923 house about a month ago for $32.5 million.

The six-bedroom landmarked house and a nonlandmarked three-bedroom guest cottage have a 17,737 combined square feet of living space, inside and out. There’s also a dock with a boat lift, a pool with a cabana, and tropical gardens, according to the listing for the property, which measures nearly 1½ acres.

Agent Liz Kelly of Hall Real Estate, meanwhile, last month listed Casa Los Manos, designed by Mizner in 1925 for a Midtown lot at 325 Chilean Ave., for $12.5 million. The sales listing describes the “lovingly restored” property as a “gated in-town Mizner enclave” featuring the architect’s signature elements: pecky cypress ceilings, ironwork balustrades, stately wood-burning fireplaces and tiled fountains.

Originally built as two houses, the renovated and expanded residence has six bedrooms and 8,474 total square feet on a lot measuring about a third of an acre.

The other Mizner properties for sale in the estate section include a completely rebuilt 1923 mansion, Villa Tranquil-la, which was constructed in 1923. Facing the ocean at 640 S. Ocean Blvd., the eight-bedroom property is listed by Condon at $42.9 million. The house has $15,721 total square feet.

And Angle has the $16.95 million listing for 12 Lagomar Road. Much renovated, that house was once part of a much larger Mizner mansion built in 1928.

The renovation earned the 2012 Ballinger Award from the Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach. With 8,714 square feet and five bedrooms, the house isn’t landmarked. Darrell Hofheinz writes about real estate and edits Home & Loggia. He welcomes news items about Palm Beach real estate for this column. Email, call 820-3831 or tweet@PBDN_Hofheinz.

Originally built as two houses, the renovated and expanded residence has six bedrooms and 8,474 total square feet on a lot measuring about a third of an acre.



Dear Craig, We are extremely pleased with the manner and professionalism in which you handled the sale of our property in Old Marsh. Not only are you knowledgeable and professional, you are also pleasure to work with. Your business judgement and knowledge of the market is impeccable.  As a result, you set the high-water mark in Old […]

- James & Anne Louise D’Loughy

Our experience with Heather and Craig Bretzlaff was one that went beyond the normal call of duty for a real estate firm. Heather was relentless in exploring endless options in finding exactly what we needed for our family, highly due to the fact that her knowledge of the business is top rate. She undoubtedly found […]

- Chris and Kim Havlicek

“Craig and Heather Bretzlaff have done a terrific job in the sale of our Steeplechase home. Craig and Heather’s personal interest, attention to detail, patience, and honesty are huge attributes and have played a large part in the successful sale of our home. Their sincere effort has made the sale process smooth and uneventful.” Paul and […]

- Paul and Cathy Sabatello

Craig and Heather’s marketing approach and personal commitment throughout the listing and sale of our home was second to none. This together with their high level of professionalism and ability to communicate with other brokers is what sets them apart in an ever competitive industry, and ultimately solidified the sale of our home.


Water Club

Your patience with us over the last few years in helping us to find our rental and then our new Florida residence was extremely helpful. Both of your knowledge of the various market sectors in this part of southeast Florida was extremely valuable and your patience with us and your attention to detail has been very impressive. Many of our friends are beginning to "migrate" to southern Florida and we obviously will send them all your way as they start to explore our part of the world. Thanks again for your professionalism, enthusiasm, and most importantly your honesty.


13200 Marsh Landing

When we set out to buy our "dream house" we had a list of many features we knew we wanted. However, finding the perfect home that felt just right was a challenge. Heather and Craig were very efficient in scheduling numerous showings. Throughout that process they proved very adept at sorting out our very subjective likes and dislikes. Eventually they led us to the perfect home - one, in fact, we had originally passed on viewing. It turned out to be ideal and we are now thrilled to be living in our new home. Not only were Craig and Heather very helpful in negotiating the purchase of the new home, they were also able to sell our former nearby home for the best square foot price in the community. They are the best!


133 Echo Drive

Anne and I are so very grateful for the magnificent job you did in finding our new home in Jupiter Florida. Your professionalism exemplified itself at every turn from the search process, through negotiations and closing. Every step of the way we felt confident that you would guide us to making the right decision. You were responsive, courteous, and professional at all times. We are very fortunate that we had you to take us through this whole difficult process. We have already recommended you to a friend and would turn to no one else should we need a real estate broker in the future. Thanks again for everything.


13020 Hammock Crossing

A little over two years ago my wife and I had the pleasure of meeting Craig and Heather Bretzlaff. I had played golf at Old Marsh Golf Club numerous times and each time I played I felt a certain draw to the community. We decided to look into purchasing a home at Old Marsh. I was fortunate to meet Heather who took us under her wing and guided us through various homes based on what was important to us. We fell in love with a beautiful home built and owned by Gary Purucker. Heather made sure that both parties felt that the transaction was equitable. During the process she exhibited true professionalism and integrity. Because of our dealings with her we have made life long friends with Craig and Heather as well as the Purucker family. I hope it will be years before we purchase another home but should we be in the market to buy or sell, the first call will be to Heather and Craig Bretzlaff. I have referred them to many of my friends and their experience has mirrored ours. I could not recommend them highly enough.


13340 Marsh Landing

Heather has proved to be an invaluable asset in the marketing and sale of my properties in Old Marsh Golf Club and Mirasol Country Club. She found the perfect buyers and the deals were seamless. She also represented me in the purchase of a property in Mirasol Country Club. She secured the deal with a professional approach all the while at the price I was willing to pay. I plan on using her and Craig in any future real estate dealings I have.


Professionalism. Integrity. Confidence. These buzzwords have become over-used, but they accurately describe Craig and Heather Bretzlaff. We have recommended them many times in the past and will continue to do so going forward.


11724 Cardena Court

Probably the single most important reason for getting the job done in a remarkably short time was your cheerful, competent and knowledgeable dealing with the prospective buyers. Without that we could still be looking for a buyer. Anyone can show a house—few can do it and find a way to make it compelling as well.


10121 Enchanted Oak

Craig and Heather are professional and efficient, but most importantly, they are genuine and gracious individuals; ultimately having their client’s best interests in mind at all times. A superior team offering proven results.


232 Locha Drive

Heather and Craig Bretzlaff acted as my agents on the sale of my residence in a prestigious gated golfing community in Florida. Dealing with them was an extremely pleasant and productive experience starting with their input on the proper asking price which was backed up by information and statistics that others did not provide. When a prospective buyer materialized, Craig and Heather worked efficiently and effectively with the buyer to establish the proper sales price. The buyer was traveling at the time and both Craig and Heather maintained contact with the buyer on a daily basis and the transaction was completed to my satisfaction, and in a timely fashion. I was extremely satisfied with their patience, knowledge, and determination and consider the experience to have been very professional and pleasant.


1558 North Ocean Blvd

Doing business with the two of you is the best of both worlds. Heather, your knowledge of the real estate market and your long experience in the building industry. Craig, your extensive insights to the golf market and the financial aspects of real estate were invaluable. I appreciate the constant follow up after our initial real estate experience; both from helping me with add on land purchases, real estate tax advice and market insights. I am convinced that the purchase of my Palm Beach Home will be a great investment for my family long term.



Craig A. Bretzlaff


Executive Director of Luxury Sales


Heather Purucker Bretzlaff


Executive Director of Luxury Sales